Polenta With Wild Mushrooms and Marinara Sauce Recipe (2024)

Ratings

5

out of 5

308

user ratings

Your rating

or to rate this recipe.

Have you cooked this?

or to mark this recipe as cooked.

Private Notes

Leave a Private Note on this recipe and see it here.

Cooking Notes

Thomas Sherman

In my household, polenta topped with something, i.e. wild mushrooms, poached egg, sautéed shrimp or sausage, has become the comfort food of choice. This is a great recipe. Add a bay leaf to the cooking polenta for a perfect extra note.

B. Tracy Madison

The polenta about which Martha writes has no relation to commercially available polenta. They cook differently. I have been using the Anson Mills products, mostly the grits which are from pre-Columbian corn varieties, since I learned about them from a Wisconsin Public Radio program. The only place you can buy these grains is from the website, www.ansonmills.com. They are fresh, so are shipped frozen and must be stored in the freezer. And they area as good as Martha says.

Mary Durfee

Fantastic recipe, tried it now am busy coming up with variations, thinking carmalized onion and blue cheese.

Stan

Have made this twice-delicious both times.

I used a polenta purchased loose (not boxed) at Fairway. I found it was ready much earlier than the recipe calls for-about 20 minutes less time. Am I using a polenta different from the one called for, or not cooking it properly? Any thoughts are welcome.

mae

For those of you in NYC, the Regional Grains Project carries polenta in farmers markets around town; check Greenmarket website. All of their grains & beans are super fresh, & this dish came out great again even though I too used jarred marinara from the Meatball Shop. The 2 lbs of oyster & baby bellas mushrooms I used smothered the dish making it very veggie centric!

Jen

Wow. This is simple and delicious. All they components are key layered together as each on there own is mild in flavor.

Viva

Absolutely delicious!

Joe

I accidentally burned my tomato sauce, so made do without it--still quite delicious!

Laurie

This is yummy! The marinara adds a lot; would be bland without it.

Tracey Jenkins

Great Recipe. Got my husband to eat some mushrooms!

quaasam

very nice. Soul food. Will do it again.

JBD

Fine if not better with button and/or cremini mushrooms.

Sirena

DELICIOUS!!! Used an even combination of maitake, oyster, and chanterelles. Opted for sage vs. rosemary. Heated up Victoria White Linen Marina Sauce (our favorite bottled) in the microwave. Added sauteed spinach with garlic between the marinara and mushrooms the second time we made this. Made a delicious dish even tastier and healthier! For Step 4, found it better to cook the mushrooms and put aside. Then cook the shallots, garlic and herbs. Once tender, add back in the mushrooms.

Ben Miller

Very good. Skipped out on the tomato sauce to avoid dirtying an extra pan and instead added some more chopped parsley and lemon zest to the seared mushrooms to get the freshness and acid in. Also used dried mushroom stock for the polenta for more flavor.

Ginny

Didn’t have enough mushrooms to make a pound so I added canned artichoke hearts, a bit of cream, a pinch of red pepper flakes and tossed in a Parmesan rind. Loved it. Polenta is a pretty blank canvas so there are lots of ways to spruce this up.

mae

For those of you in NYC, the Regional Grains Project carries polenta in farmers markets around town; check Greenmarket website. All of their grains & beans are super fresh, & this dish came out great again even though I too used jarred marinara from the Meatball Shop. The 2 lbs of oyster & baby bellas mushrooms I used smothered the dish making it very veggie centric!

Douglas Branch

Delicious. I, too, found that the polenta cooked a lot quicker than the recipe said. Much quicker. Done in 20 minutes, maybe. Jarred marinara, just fine. You don't have that much of it, anyway. And I found that doing 3/4 of this recipe, more or less, fed two of us well. I doubt the full recipe would feed four happily. Mixture of trumpet and shiitake mushrooms, but I bet any good mix would be delicious. Used more cheese, too.

Lydia

Super easy (OK, I cheated on making the polenta from scratch, as have excellent local polenta), served with side dish of fava beans, which by the way are extremely tasty with the polenta. Nice mix of flavors that the eater can mix as desired.

Lydia

Super easy (OK, I cheated on making the polenta from scratch, as have excellent local polenta), served with side dish of fava beans, which by the way are extremely tasty with the polenta. Nice mix of flavors that the eater can mix as desired.

Michael

The polenta is a bit bland. Next time I will use chicken or vegetable stock instead of water and add more cheese.

Private notes are only visible to you.

Polenta With Wild Mushrooms and Marinara Sauce Recipe (2024)

FAQs

How do you make Martha Stewart polenta? ›

In a large, deep saucepan, bring 5 cups of water to a boil. While whisking constantly, add polenta in a slow, steady stream. Reduce heat to medium, cook until thickened, stirring occasionally with a wooden spoon, about 15 minutes. Remove pan from heat and stir in cheese, heavy cream, and butter.

Should polenta be soaked before cooking? ›

A ratio of five parts liquid to one part cornmeal by volume produces polenta that's fully hydrated and cooked through, without any little raw, gritty bits. An optional presoaking step helps hydrate the cornmeal and cuts down on actual cooking time.

What is wild mushroom sauce made of? ›

Heat the oil in a frying pan and gently fry the onion and garlic for 3-4 minutes. Add the mushrooms and continue to cook for 4-5 minutes. Pour in the white wine and simmer until reduced slightly, then pour in the cream. Season well with salt and freshly ground black pepper and simmer gently for about five minutes.

Why is my polenta gummy? ›

You want coarse, stone-ground yellow corn to make the most delicious polenta. Instant polenta is parboiled, and while it does cook in less time than it takes to boil water, the trade-off is that the final product is often a gummy, gloopy mess. So, always avoid it. For the real deal, the extra time is worth it.

How do you make polenta taste better? ›

Cooked veggies are the perfect way to add hearty texture, richness, and flavor to creamy polenta. Try pairing it with roasted broccoli, Brussels sprouts, tomatoes, butternut squash, or cauliflower, with grilled mixed vegetables or zucchini, or with sautéed mushrooms.

What is the best way to eat polenta? ›

Polenta, slow simmered ground corn, is eaten in many ways, as a main or side dish. It can be served simply, with just butter and cheese, or topped with sauce. It is often spread out to dry a bit and then baked, fried or grilled.

Do you have to stir polenta constantly? ›

Surprisingly, the creamiest polenta comes from the coarsest cornmeal. And the less you stir it, the better.

Is polenta good for you? ›

Polenta is a healthy gluten-free grain and good source of antioxidants that help protect your eyes and reduce your risk of certain chronic diseases. It shouldn't negatively affect your blood sugar levels as long as you stick to a reasonable portion size.

What is the difference between a mushroom and a wild mushroom? ›

Wild mushrooms from nature and mushrooms grown for commercial purposes on mushroom farms are genetically identical but not equal in type and amount of metabolites, that is, containing medicinal substances.

Is Worcestershire sauce the same as mushroom ketchup? ›

It is one of the most classic of British condiments. Commercial brands make in the UK are good but hard to find in the United States, where they also tend to be overpriced. While you can substitute Worcestershire or soy sauce, the flavor is not quite the same, so here is a recipe for homemade mushroom ketchup.

What is the wild mushroom that tastes like chicken? ›

Some species, especially Laetiporus sulphureus, are commonly known as sulphur shelf, chicken of the woods, the chicken mushroom, or the chicken fungus because it is often described as tasting like and having a texture similar to that of chicken meat.

Can you overcook polenta? ›

Yes, you can overcook polenta but the good news is that it is easy to correct. You can adjust the texture again with more liquid until your ratio is perfect. Just remember to taste it before serving since with the addition of more liquid, it may have lost its flavor.

Why isn't my polenta creamy? ›

The 45 minutes of cooking time is crucial. I always thought my polenta looked done after 15 or 20 minutes of cooking, but just because it's thickened doesn't mean the cornmeal has cooked through. Keep on cooking until it tastes creamy, corny, and a little bit sweet. That extra time makes all the difference.

How to tell if polenta is done? ›

Polenta is done when texture is creamy and the individual grains are tender. Turn off heat and gently stir 2 tablespoons butter into polenta until butter partially melts; mix 1/2 cup Parmigiano-Reggiano cheese into polenta until cheese has melted. Cover and let stand for 5 minutes to thicken.

What makes the best polenta? ›

The best polenta is made from stone ground corn, which comes in a coarse, medium, or fine grind. Cornmeal labeled polenta is usually a coarse-grind, but you can make the dish with a medium or fine-grind. Or, use a combination of grinds, which is how I like it.

Is there a difference between cornmeal and polenta? ›

Differences between cornmeal and polenta

Cornmeal is made by grinding dried corn kernels – yellow, white or blue – into fine, medium and coarse textures, while polenta is made from a specific variety of corn called flint corn. Polenta also has a coarser texture than most types of cornmeal.

How did Italians make polenta before corn? ›

In ancient Rome, a softer type of polenta made with cooked ground spelt was called 'pultem'. When corn was brought to Europe from America, it took the place of spelt as polenta's main ingredient.

How much liquid for 1 cup of polenta? ›

Polenta is nothing more than coarsely ground cornmeal. The classic ratio is 1 part polenta to 4 parts water, but I like to measure the polenta just a little scant of a full cup. I often use chicken broth instead of water.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Geoffrey Lueilwitz

Last Updated:

Views: 6430

Rating: 5 / 5 (80 voted)

Reviews: 95% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Geoffrey Lueilwitz

Birthday: 1997-03-23

Address: 74183 Thomas Course, Port Micheal, OK 55446-1529

Phone: +13408645881558

Job: Global Representative

Hobby: Sailing, Vehicle restoration, Rowing, Ghost hunting, Scrapbooking, Rugby, Board sports

Introduction: My name is Geoffrey Lueilwitz, I am a zealous, encouraging, sparkling, enchanting, graceful, faithful, nice person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.