Peanut Butter No-Bake Cookies (2024)

by Danielle Rye on July 2, 2018 210 comments »

These Peanut Butter No-Bake Cookies are full of peanut butter flavor, only require a few simple ingredients, and are incredibly easy to make!

If I had to choose a favorite cookie recipe from my childhood, it would hands-down be these Classic No-Bake Cookies. I shared the recipe for those cookies last year and ever since then, they have been my top cookie recipe. It makes me so happy that so many of you love the same recipes that I do!

Over the last year, I’ve had several requests for a peanut butter version of my no-bake cookies. So a couple weeks ago I took my no-bake cookie recipe and tweaked it to make a super peanut buttery version. It took a few attempts but I finally got the recipe just right and I have to say, these cookies are just as good as the chocolate version!

These cookies are also ridiculously simple to throw together for those times when you need a quick and simple dessert. You only need six ingredients and about 20 minutes to prepare them!

To make these peanut butter no-bake cookies, you’ll start out with some butter, granulated sugar, and milk. You’ll melt the mixture down then bring it to a rolling boil and allow it to boil for one minute.

Here’s the tricky part with no-bake cookies, sometimes they don’t set up properly. I’ve been making no-bake cookies for years now and I’ve found that one of the main reasons is that the mixture doesn’t boil long enough before you add the rest of the ingredients.

You don’t want to set your timer for 60 seconds as soon as you see a few bubbles. You’ll start to see the mixture bubble around the edges, then bubble a little, then it will come to a rolling boil where the top is completely covered and bubbling vigorously. This is when you want to set your timer for 60 seconds! If you set it too soon, then it’s likely that your cookies will not set up properly.

Once the mixture has boiled, you’ll remove it from the heat and stir in some peanut butter and vanilla extract. When it comes to the peanut butter for no-bake cookies, I have not tested these with natural peanut butter. Iprefer to use a peanut butter like Jif or Skippy to make sure they set up properly and aren’t too soft.

And, of course, the final ingredient is some quick-cooking oats. When it comes to baked oatmeal cookies, I love old-fashioned rolled oats.But when it comes to no-bake cookies, I prefer to use quick-cooking oats because they’re smaller. If you only have old-fashioned rolled oats you can pulse them a few times in a food processor to break them down a little more.

One important thing with these no-bake cookies, they do take a little longer to set up. If you’ve made my chocolate no-bake cookies you know that they’ll usually start to set up after about 20 minutes or so. I find that these need about 45 minutes to an hour to really set up because of the extra peanut butter in them.

The cookies will continue to set up even more after that, but they’re still delicious even when they’re a little warm!

published on Jul 2, 2018

210 commentsLeave a comment »