Orange Creamsicle MOONSHINE! - My Incredible Recipes (2025)

Home » Latest Recipes » Orange Creamsicle MOONSHINE!

By Incredible Recipes | 43 Comments | Posted: | Updated:

This post may contain affiliate links.

As everyone has probably already seen, my Strawberry Moonshine recipe went completely CRAZY viral all over the internet, Facebook & Pinterest. Yes, its THAT good 😉

I had to come back with another one that I KNOW everyone will love! CREAMSICLE MOONSHINE!!

Orange Creamsicle MOONSHINE! - My Incredible Recipes (1)

I have another couple different kinds of moonshines coming out in the next couple weeks, so please stay tuned!

Orange Creamsicle MOONSHINE! - My Incredible Recipes (2)

I have a SKITTLES one coming very soon that I know will be a superstar hit- its so delicious!

Orange Creamsicle MOONSHINE! - My Incredible Recipes (3)

Who doesnt love creamsicles? Perfect for Summer!

Please remember to SHARE on Facebook and PIN IT!

Orange Creamsicle MOONSHINE!

Ingredients

  • 1 gallon Orange juice no pulp
  • 1 1/2 cup Sugar
  • 2 tbsp Vanilla extract
  • 1/2 cup French vanilla liquid coffee creamer
  • 3 cup 190 proof everclear
  • 1/2 cup Vanilla vodka
  • Mason jars w/ lids

Instructions

  • Using a big pot, bring to a boil the orange juice, sugar, vanilla extract and the vanilla coffee creamer.

  • Stir until creamer is fully incorporated

  • Cool to room temp for about 1 hour

  • Add everclear and vodka to your orange mix

  • Stir

  • Pour your moonshine into your mason jars and seal closed

  • Refrigerate

  • Let sit for at least 2 weeks

  • Shake it before serving

  • Enjoy

Did you make this recipe?

Make sure to follow on Pinterest for more recipes!

Orange Creamsicle MOONSHINE! - My Incredible Recipes (4)

Reader Interactions

    Leave A Reply!

    This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

    Comments & Reviews

  1. Sue says

    This looks good though I don’t drink often I think chilled this would be great

    Reply

    • Mary says

      This looks delicious.. Put in blender and make it a smoothy

      Reply

    • Mark Valente says

      it does say refrigerate and sit for 2 weeks…….so uhm yeah it would be chilled…. =P

      Pour me some of that!!! \=/\=/\=/\=/

      Reply

      • Toni Gattie says

        The hardest part is letting it sit 2 weeks!!!

        Reply

  2. Owner says

    This sounds good. I was wondering, Have you determined the alcohol content of the finished product?

    Reply

  3. Lynn B says

    Tried it !! Damn it’s Awesome !!!

    Reply

    • Cindy Curtiss says

      Thanks for letting us know 🙂 It looks awesome!!!!!

      Reply

  4. Cindy leclair says

    Hi can you plse tell me what everytime is. Idn know if we have it here. So may have to substitute. Thx 🙂

    Reply

    • Amber B says

      Everclear is actually illegal to purchase in some states, like Pennsylvania. It’s alcohol content is too high. We have to drive to Delaware or Maryland to buy it.

      Reply

    • josh says

      190 proof Everclear. it is not sold in all states, we only have 150 proof, but you should be able to find 190 proof grain alcohol in most liquor stores.

      Reply

    • Dusty Corrals says

      I think you meant Everclear, it’s grain alcohol. As far as I know it’s the only pure grain alcohol sold. Not all states allow the sale of it.

      Reply

    • Alice says

      Another word for ever clear is moonshine! Does that help?

      Reply

    • Henry says

      Everclear is pure grain alcohol, not sold in all states

      Reply

  5. Michelle Longtine says

    Holy Moly! This sounds so good for a summer party!

    Reply

  6. Incredible Recipes says

    Everclear can be found at almost all liquor stores 🙂 If they dont carry it, ask them what they would recommend as a good substitute for it 🙂

    Reply

    • Heidi Scola says

      When you say seal them, do you seal them in the boiling water?? And do you leave them in the refrigerator until you want to drink them?

  7. Liz says

    Can you substitute the everclear with something else?

    Reply

  8. Lynda Keller says

    Yummy, can’t wait!!!

    Reply

  9. rick says

    would 100 proof moon shine work instead of the everclear??

    Reply

  10. Sheila Nugent-Smith says

    Can’t wait to make this. How long will it last?

    Reply

  11. Robin says

    Does it have to be stored in glass containers?

    Reply

  12. Anne says

    Why does it need to sit in fridge for two weeks? Would it taste bad or be bad if it was made the night before a party and sat in fridge only overnight?

    How thick is it? I was thinking it would be easy to serve if I put it in my ice tea jug that has the spigot on it.

    Reply

  13. Judie Tallman says

    why do you leave it for two weeks? would it taste bad if you consume after making without waiting?

    Reply

    • Sandy says

      For all the ingredients to “Marinade” and age together. Drink no Moonshine before it’s time!

      Reply

    • Eric Cramer says

      Leaving it sits Mellows the flavor. Everclear can be quite harsh and sitting allows for the sugars and other ingredients to Marry giving it a much smoother and enjoyable drink.

      Reply

  14. Lisa Passero says

    Making it now

    Reply

  15. Sue Sutterer says

    Where do you get Everclear?

    Reply

    • Sandy says

      At the Liquor Store if it’s legal in your state.

      Reply

  16. Russell says

    How long does it stay good for?

    Reply

  17. Wendy says

    This is way to awesome. Thank you.

    Reply

  18. Bruce brungard says

    Does this have to be kept in a refrigerator all the time? Pa. Sells moonshine, my husband bought it. Its sold in canning jars.

    Reply

  19. Judith Jackson says

    how long does this stay good for.

    Reply

  20. Linda Kent says

    Sounds Yummy! Have to try this. Thanks!!

    Reply

  21. Diana stock says

    I love moonshine please send me your recipes. Thank you so much.

    Reply

  22. yourmadgamer emyspot says

    Guns of Boom Hack& Cheats. That is fairly a balancing act.

    Reply

  23. Linda says

    What is ever clear and where would you find it?

    Reply

  24. Dj says

    I have this question about forgetting to put in a 1/2 cup of vanilla vodka in your Creamsicle Moonshine recipe. Just wondering how it will affect the taste?

    Reply

  25. Kelly says

    Can you please tell me how long this will last in the fridge? If it is at my house, I am sure not very. I LOVE creamsicles!

    Reply

  26. Julie Matthews says

    Orange Creamsicle MOONSHINE! - My Incredible Recipes (5)
    Sounds delicious. Are you able to can this for “shelf stable” use at a later time ( months) later?

    Reply

  27. Donna Sellers says

    I have become known for bringing this recipe! Let me just say it’s awesome! It does spoil after awhile. I guess maybe the creamer gets old. I think it was like within one month, and was refrigerated the whole time. Anyway, just beware that you can’t keep it forever.

    Reply

  28. Brenda Maupin says

    Orange Creamsicle MOONSHINE! - My Incredible Recipes (6)
    Amazing

    Reply

Orange Creamsicle MOONSHINE! - My Incredible Recipes (2025)

FAQs

Does creamsicle moonshine go bad? ›

Storing Flavored Moonshine

Unopened flavored moonshine can last for years, un-refrigerated and away from sunlight. Like plain moonshine, flavored moonshine is best enjoyed while stored in a glass bottle. However, once opened, flavored moonshine only lasts 3-6 months in the refrigerator.

Who makes Creamsicle moonshine? ›

Thus, Junction 35's Orange Creamsicle Moonshine was born. Tasting Notes: Orange sherbet dances across the palate first, followed by creamy vanilla ice cream, melding into the classic balanced flavors of an orange creamsicle ice cream bar.

Do you have to refrigerate cream moonshine after opening? ›

Storing opened flavored moonshine in the refrigerator prolongs its shelf life. The refrigerator temperatures slow down when the sugars and added flavors go bad. Unopened flavored moonshine can last for years, un-refrigerated and away from sunlight.

How long does moonshine last in mason jars? ›

If the glass is stored closed, it will keep for at least 3-5 years. Our Moonshine does not need to have a best-before date. If the jar is already opened, it is recommended to store it closed (original lid, not the pouring lid) and in a cool place.

What soda is named for moonshine? ›

"Mountain Dew" was originally Southern and/or Scots-Irish slang for moonshine (i.e., homemade whiskey or poitín), as referenced in the Irish folk song "The Rare Old Mountain Dew", dating from 1882. Using it as the name for the soda was originally suggested by Carl E.

What liquor is moonshine most like? ›

Moonshiners across the country employed various ingredients, including corn, rye, and sugar. Moonshine has a flavor that is more like vodka than a dark-colored whiskey.

What is moonshine called now? ›

In English, moonshine is also known as mountain dew, choop, hooch (abbreviation of hoochinoo, name of a specific liquor, from Tlingit), homebrew, mulekick, shine, sneaky pete, white dog, white lightning, white/corn liquor, white/corn whiskey, pass around, firewater, and bootleg.

Is moonshine good in coke? ›

If you like whiskey and coke, you'll love moonshine and coke. This classic combination can be a good starting point for the novice moonshine drinker. If you want to get more of the earthy taste of moonshine in your cocktail, try pairing it with ginger ale (not ginger beer).

Is moonshine good with Sprite? ›

Pour the moonshine into a tumbler filled with cubed or crushed ice. Top it off with Sprite, stir well, and enjoy! For an added burst, throw in some crushed mint leaves or freshly cut slices of orange.

How can you tell if moonshine is bad? ›

Moonshine does go bad, and you can determine this by taking a small sip which will have a foul taste or taste worse than you expected. Drinking moonshine that is old or contaminated can result in adverse effects.

Does white chocolate strawberry cream moonshine go bad? ›

Hi, Scott the cream based spirits are good for 6 months after opening if kept refrigerated. Have a great day and Shine Responsibly!

Does Ole Smoky cream moonshine expire? ›

Different flavors will have different life spans. Generally they will last two years unopened and about six months after opening. They will generally last longer if you store them in the fridge after opening as well.

Does cream liquor go bad? ›

We would also recommend that cream liqueurs should be consumed within six to twelve months of opening. How do cream liqueurs spoil? Exposure to air is the greatest storage problem for cream liqueurs. Oxygen will cause the liqueur to turn brown, and may cause changes in the texture of the product.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Recommended Articles
Article information

Author: Ouida Strosin DO

Last Updated:

Views: 5975

Rating: 4.6 / 5 (56 voted)

Reviews: 87% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Ouida Strosin DO

Birthday: 1995-04-27

Address: Suite 927 930 Kilback Radial, Candidaville, TN 87795

Phone: +8561498978366

Job: Legacy Manufacturing Specialist

Hobby: Singing, Mountain biking, Water sports, Water sports, Taxidermy, Polo, Pet

Introduction: My name is Ouida Strosin DO, I am a precious, combative, spotless, modern, spotless, beautiful, precious person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.