6 Reasons You Should Never Stuff Your Turkey (2024)

Get your hands outta that cavity.

By
6 Reasons You Should Never Stuff Your Turkey (1)6 Reasons You Should Never Stuff Your Turkey (2)

When it comes to stuffing, people have strong opinions. Cornbread or cubed bread, homemade or Stove Top? Even the very name itself—"stuffing" or "dressing"? But no topic is as polarizing as whether you should load that mixture of bread, broth, and vegetables into the turkey before roasting it.

Ignore their outcries, and cite this story as your argument for why you're not stuffing your turkey any time soon. And if you want to appease the traditionalists, you could always stuff the roasted bird with cooked stuffing right before serving. The haters don't need to know you didn't do it 100 percent their way.

1. It Could Give You Salmonella Poisoning

This seems like an empty threat to anyone who routinely takes the risk by licking cookie dough off the spatula, but hear us out: Stuffing's pretty porous (all that bread!), which means that as the turkey cooks, juices containing salmonella could seep into it. If that stuffing doesn't reach 165 degrees F, the bacteria won't be killed off, meaning you're passing it on to your guests.

2. It's The Reason Your Turkey's So Dry

And scorched. Cooking the stuffing to 165 degrees F comes at a cost—it often means overcooking the bird, explains Alton Brown. Nobody wants that.

3. It Turns Gummy

Since those turkey juices seep into the stuffing as the bird cooks—and because the stuffing itself is ensconced within the poultry, acting like SPF 10,000—the side dish tends to get extra juicy, giving it a mushy, borderline gummy texture.

4. You Could Overstuff the Turkey

No, your turkey won't explode in the oven. It will, however, make it even harder to get the stuffing to cook evenly, meaning you're even more likely to get a scorched bird—or wind up with salmonella-susceptible pockets of undercooked stuffing.

5. It Can Be a Huge Time Suck

You think you're saving time by cooking the stuffing as you roast the turkey, but a stuffed bird can be so dense that it takes longer to cook overall. You're better off prepping and cooking the stuffing the day before, then warming it up in the slow cooker. Or adjusting the racks in your oven before putting the bird in so you can warm the stuffing as the turkey finishes its tanning session.

6. It Keeps You From Getting Your Aromatics On

Sure, you load up the bottom of the pan with carrots and onion and celery and thyme, but you could also be flavoring the bird from the inside out. Our guide for the best roasted turkey includes seasoning the cavity with salt and pepper and stuffing it with onion, rosemary, thyme, sage, and garlic.

Bake your stuffing in a casserole dish—or, if you prefer those crispy edges, in a muffin tin. The texture will be chewy, not gooey, and you won't have to worry as much about whether you've cooked it all the way.

Watch Next

6 Reasons You Should Never Stuff Your Turkey (3)

Advertisem*nt - Continue Reading Below

6 Reasons You Should Never Stuff Your Turkey (2024)

FAQs

6 Reasons You Should Never Stuff Your Turkey? ›

At temperatures below 165°F you risk exposure to salmonella or E. coli, two very scary and gross bacteria. The problem with stuffing your roast turkey is that when the turkey's meat is safely cooked, the stuffing inside still is not.

Why should you not stuff a turkey? ›

At temperatures below 165°F you risk exposure to salmonella or E. coli, two very scary and gross bacteria. The problem with stuffing your roast turkey is that when the turkey's meat is safely cooked, the stuffing inside still is not.

What to put in a turkey if you don't stuff it? ›

Onion, celery and carrot: These chopped vegetables are placed inside the cavity. These help to add flavor and also keep the turkey moist as they steam. Other vegetables you can use are squashes or peppers. Seasonings & Herbs: Salt, pepper, fresh rosemary and sage.

Should you put anything in the cavity of a turkey? ›

Stuffing cooked inside the turkey cavities is delicious, but it does slow down the cooking time and could be a potential health hazard if done incorrectly.

Is putting stuffing in a turkey safe? ›

Here's an important Thanksgiving food safety tip that will surprise many: USDA doesn't recommend stuffing a whole turkey. The practice increases the risk of cross-contamination and takes the turkey longer to cook. Cook stuffing separately instead.

Is it better to cook a turkey without stuffing? ›

The United States Department of Agriculture ( USDA ) recommends cooking the stuffing out side of the bird. Bacteria can survive in stuffing that has not reached 165 F, possibly resulting in foodborne illness. Some people feel that stuffing has a better taste and is moister when prepared in the turkey.

What is the best way to brine a turkey? ›

Using the ratio of one cup kosher salt to one cup sugar per gallon of water, combine all your brine ingredients in a large pot, and bring to a boil to dissolve the salt and sugar. Remember that you may add aromatics like peppercorns, bay leaves, or citrus for flavor in the brine. Allow the solution to cool completely.

What is the best food to stuff a turkey with? ›

Alliums: Add quartered onions, shallots, leeks, or garlic cloves for a delicious, earthy aroma. Fruits: Insert quarters of apple, lemon, orange, lime, or even grapefruit to add moisture and brightness to the turkey. You can even go with dried fruit, like cranberries, to double down on the autumn vibes.

Can I put potatoes under my turkey? ›

Preheat oven to 350 degrees F or if you have a convection oven 325 degrees F convection roast mode. Spray a large roasting pan with non-stick spray. Evenly place the potatoes on the bottom of the pan. Place the turkey on top of the potatoes.

Why stuff a turkey with apples and oranges? ›

As to why you should do this, Scott explains "when you put apples inside the turkey, the steam, vapor, and flavor from roasting the apples is being concentrated inside the turkey and being absorbed into the turkey meat." He says this allows "the sweet taste of the apples [to] permeate... into the bird," which in turn " ...

Why would you put toothpicks in a turkey before cooking? ›

Pin the skin

This turkey tip will keep the skin from shrinking back during cooking, exposing and drying out the meat. Use toothpicks to pin the skin to the meat underneath, or to pin the skin closed over the cavity. You can also use this trick to secure tears in the skin.

Do you rinse the inside of a turkey? ›

Do you wash the inside of a turkey before cooking it? Nope! Just like with the outside of a turkey, there's no need to rinse the cavity. All you need to worry about is removing the neck and giblets.

What can I put inside a turkey besides stuffing? ›

Herbs of all kinds are also necessary for adding flavor. Stuff a bundle of fresh herbs right into the cavity. The flavor and aroma of these greens will permeate the poultry as it cooks. Try using any combination of the following for delicious results: thyme, rosemary, sage, tarragon, marjoram, parsley and oregano.

How long does an unstuffed turkey take to cook? ›

Regular Oven 325°
WeightCook Time (Unstuffed)Cook Time (Stuffed)
10-18 lbs.3-3½ hrs.3¾-4½ hrs.
18-22 lbs.3½-4 hrs.4½-5 hrs.
22-24 lbs.4-4½ hrs.5-5½ hrs.
24-30 lbs.4½-5 hrs.5½-6¼ hrs.
2 more rows

How long can stuffing sit in turkey? ›

No, stuffing a turkey the night before gives bacteria more time to soak into your stuffing, increasing the risk of foodborne illness. To prevent this, add the prepared stuffing to the turkey just before cooking.

What happens when you stuff a turkey? ›

As the turkey cooks, its juices drip onto the stuffing, infusing the bread and vegetables with extra flavor. Some people also think the practice yields a moister stuffing, while others "do it to save space in the oven," says Baker.

What are the possible risks of stuffing poultry? ›

Cooking stuffed poultry, pork chops, and other meat can be somewhat riskier than cooking them unstuffed. Bacteria can survive in stuffing that has not reached the safe minimum internal temperature of 165 °F, possibly resulting in foodborne illness.

Does an unstuffed turkey cook faster? ›

10. Calculate turkey cooking time and temperature. The simplest way to figure out turkey roasting times is to calculate 13 minutes per pound at 350°F for an unstuffed turkey (that's about 3 hours for a 12- to 14-lb. turkey), or 15 minutes per pound for a stuffed turkey.

Do you stuff a turkey with hot or cold stuffing? ›

usually about 30 to 40 minutes until it's warm, and then take off the foil so the top can crisp up, and it's absolutely delicious. ... If you want to stuff your bird, you should actually microwave the stuffing, and then you put hot stuffing inside the turkey.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Kieth Sipes

Last Updated:

Views: 6365

Rating: 4.7 / 5 (47 voted)

Reviews: 86% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Kieth Sipes

Birthday: 2001-04-14

Address: Suite 492 62479 Champlin Loop, South Catrice, MS 57271

Phone: +9663362133320

Job: District Sales Analyst

Hobby: Digital arts, Dance, Ghost hunting, Worldbuilding, Kayaking, Table tennis, 3D printing

Introduction: My name is Kieth Sipes, I am a zany, rich, courageous, powerful, faithful, jolly, excited person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.